Republican Presidential Debate (New Hampshire)
Tonight, on ABC, six of the remaining Republican Presidential contenders square off live from New Hampshire. Sponsored by ABC and Facebook, this important debate is just a few days away from the NH primary.
For the Republicans, we will see John McCain, Mitt Romney, Mike Huckabee, Rudy Giuliani, Fred Thompson and Ron Paul.
7:07p
A different format to start off with. Charlie Gibson will have the candidates sit down and try to talk to each other.
7:11p
Will the candidate embrace the Bush foreign policy, or run away from it. Huckabee starts off with being asked to defend his comments about the US having a bunker mentality. Giuliani gives Bush credit for putting the US on offense instead of defense, and knocks Bill Clinton for slashing the military.
7:16p
McCain also gives Bush credit for the doctrine the US follows, and believes that the country is safer now. He points out that he also advocated the surge strategy before anyone else did. He wraps things up by giving Giuliani credit for handling 9/11
Romney points out that Bush is not arrogant, and that the US owes him a debt of gratitude for what he has done to make the US safer (who knew that Bush would be given this much support - especially in New Hampshire - it seems risky considering the independent nature of the state).
7:27p
Romney and Huckabee going after each other; McCain is in the corner, keeping quiet, holding onto his lead and smiling as the others leave him alone.
7:30p
I love the spirited back-and-forth. Charlie Gibson is going to have to remind everyone that he is paying for this microphone.
7:34p
Gibson wants McCain and Romney to talk about (to paraphrase) why they hate each other and accuse each other of following polls to create opinion. Neither takes the bait and keeps it civil. Gibson even points out that they both seem different tonight, and not like the candidates who are running the television commercials.
7:38p
Gibson goes right down the line and calls out each candidate for political/issue changes that they have made over the course of their lives, under the guise of scoring political points.
7:39p
I had to rewind that to watch it again; it was an amazing moment that I have not seen before from the media...especially in a national televised debate. I would love to see him do that to the Democrats as well just to see what he says about them.
7:44p
Health care is now the topic, and Gibson points out that the basic Republican philosophy is that free-market consumer-purchased insurance is better than government run. All the candidates generally believe that the US has the best health care system in the world, and as Giuliani said, this is where Canadians and the world come to get treated.
Ron Paul points out that we would have the money for a great health care system if we ended the war and got the billions back.
7:50p
You can tell I am a political junkie - I forgot there were NFL playoff games going on tonight. BTW, final score: Seattle Seahawks 35 Washington Redskins 14
7:53p
Some interesting ideas coming out about health care that I have never heard before. I want to know a little more about how Massachusetts set up a system where individual families could purchase insurance, and the prices of premiums eventually dropped to be half of where they started.
7:58p
McCain takes on pharmaceutical company policies; Romney defends how the companies operate.
8:00p
Commercial time. Besides the YouTube debate, this is the most substantive debate I have seen during this race. I really like how the candidates can speak to each other, and how fewer people allows for more time to answer (it ought to be even better for the Democrats).
8:05p
Second half starts, with direct questions to candidates and time limits. We start off with immigration, and McCain is reminded about the last debate in New Hampshire where he was hammered on the topic - coming on the heels of a failed Senate bill (remember when everyone thought McCain was close to dropping out?).
8:10p
Romney - all illegal immigrants need to leave the country and can then apply for entry and citizenship.
Giuliani - it is impossible to get everyone out. Focus on the people who are committing crimes and get them out first.
McCain and Romney go after each other. McCain calls him out on the attack ads he has been running about McCain's amnesty plan.
8:13p
(McCain to Romney) 'It is easy to get mis-quoted when you change your position on issues.' (or something close to that - whatever the words, it got an 'oooooooo' from the audience)
8:15p
Giuliani brings up the Reagan microphone incident (lol - video above) and says that Reagan's view on immigration would put him in one of Mitt's negative ads.
8:19p
Paul and Huckabee have been strangely quiet about this topic. Neither has spoken - and Gibson calls out Huckabee, saying he is sitting there with a smile on his face letting the others fight it out.
8:24p
Why to not vote for Obama?
Romney - he wants government to take over health care; Washington needs to change, and Romney has the experience of doing it
Thompson - Obama has adopted the position of every liberal interest group; his alternative to all issues is to have the federal government solve the problem
McCain - says that Romney is the 'candidate of change' (laughs from crowd); Obama does not have the knowledge and experience to do the job
Giuliani - Obama has never had executive experience; change is a concept, but change could be very bad versus good
Huckabee - differences on 2nd and 10th amendments, life, national defense, taxes, same sex marriage; points out that Obama has touched a chord with the voters, and has excited people about this election, and warns the party about not recognizing this fact
Paul - their campaigns are similar, using and welcoming young people; Paul talks more about economics and monetary policy, where Obama talks more about the welfare state
8:35p
Does it make Obama happy that he has the assumed the role of presumed Democratic nominee for purposes of these types of questions?
8:37p
Thompson would not tax excess profits of the oil companies, pointing out that we are not a country that regulates our economy. At least he is honest, by also pointing out that we are not going to be energy independent any time soon.
8:42p
And.....we're done.
WOW! How many times could Romney be accused of changing his positions?
All in all, I think Romney handled himself very well, and you could tell that he and McCain were the top two by the way they went at each other. Huckabee disappeared entirely (since no one thinks he can win in New Hampshire, it may have been his philosophy to get through this without doing any harm - but leaders should not act this way), and Giuliani reminded everyone that he is still running. Thompson woke up long enough to participate and show how he could be a force if he wanted to be. Who thought Paul would outlast Brownback, Hunter and Tancredo to make the final six?
Kudos to ABC for this debate. The first half went extremely well, and Gibson gave them all enough freedom to mix it up, and yet knew when to reign them in. I have to look this up to see if the moderators have been announced yet for the general election debates, but tonight was Gibson's application for doing one of them.
Gibson is also going to have candidates from both parties on stage at the same time. And out come the candidates - the audience gives them a well-deserved standing ovation. Onto the Democratic debate.
-RSKnopfJr




A special 


Late announcement from the Illinois Republican Party...


After a 90+ minute delay in announcing the results (due to problems with the Diebold machines counting the ballots), the results are in for the Ames Straw Poll:
Recent Comments